JournalStrategy1 min read

When a feature should not use AI

Part of designing AI products well is knowing where a model does not belong. Four signs we look for before reaching for one.

A marble head of a youth in profile, printed in white dots on blue

We build AI products for a living, and one of the most useful things we do for clients is talk them out of AI in the wrong places. A model adds cost, latency and uncertainty. It earns its place only where it does something a simpler system cannot.

The answer is already known

If a rule, a lookup or a well-designed form produces the right result every time, use it. Determinism is a feature. People notice when a button that should always do the same thing does something slightly different on Tuesday.

Mistakes are expensive and invisible

Where an error is costly and hard to spot, such as a figure in an invoice or a field in a contract, a model should suggest and a person should confirm. If the design cannot make that review fast and natural, the feature is not ready for AI yet.

Speed matters more than nuance

Some interactions need to feel instant. A search box that waits two seconds for a model to rephrase the query feels broken, even if the results are better. Often the right design is a fast conventional result first, with the AI layer arriving after.

Nobody asked for it

The most common sign is the simplest. If the feature exists because AI is expected rather than because a user is stuck, it will be ignored. We start from the moment people struggle, and only then ask whether a model is the best way through it.

The best AI feature is often the one you decided not to build, so the right one gets all of your attention.

More from the journal

  1. Design / 3 min

    Designing for calibrated trust

    The goal of an AI interface is not more trust. It is the right amount. Two decades of human-AI research, distilled into the design moves we reach for first.

  2. Engineering / 4 min

    Look at the data: evals for AI products

    Most AI features fail quietly, in ways no dashboard predicted. The fix is unglamorous: read real outputs, name the failures, and measure only those.

  3. Strategy / 3 min

    Start with a workflow, not an agent

    Agents are the most exciting pattern in AI products, and often the wrong first one. Why we begin with the simplest system that could work, and when we graduate.

  4. Design / 2 min

    Design is the interface to the model

    Two products can call the same model and feel nothing alike. The difference is almost never the prompt. It is the design around it.

  5. Engineering / 1 min

    Build for the next model, not this one

    The model you launch on will not be the model you run in a year. A few architectural habits keep that change cheap.